Court case — California Court of Appeal · DUI causing injury
People v. Schultz: a prosecutor may argue that refusing field sobriety tests shows consciousness of guilt
Charged with DUI? Start your free case review.
One local DUI lawyer reads exactly what you send and calls you back.
1. You submit → 2. We pass it along, exactly as entered → 3. One local lawyer receives it
DUICriminalDefenseLawyer.com is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Submitting this form does not create an attorney–client relationship.
On November 18, 2026, the California Court of Appeal, Fifth Appellate District, affirmed the DUI convictions of Marian P. Schultz, who was arrested on suspicion of DUI after his truck, doing “doughnuts” in a Kern County street, struck a motorcycle and a car in April 2019. A jury convicted him of driving under the influence causing bodily injury and of driving with a blood-alcohol content of 0.08 percent or more causing injury, with great bodily injury enhancements, and he was sentenced to six years and four months in prison. His lawyer on appeal, Richard Oberto, argued that the prosecutor committed misconduct by urging the jury to treat his refusal to perform field sobriety tests as consciousness of guilt, and that the trial court should have dismissed the great bodily injury enhancements under Penal Code §1385, subdivision (c). The court rejected both arguments. Mr. Schultz was presumed innocent at his trial; the jury convicted him, and that judgment now stands affirmed.
The crash and the arrest, as the opinion states them
According to the opinion, at about 10:00 p.m. on April 13, 2019, drivers near Hosking Avenue and Wible Road in Kern County saw a truck performing doughnuts in the middle of the street. The truck turned across the lanes and struck a motorcycle carrying Armandeep Singh and his passenger, Arshdeep Gill, and a car driven by Jerry DeGuzman. Officers who contacted Mr. Schultz described an odor of alcohol, red and watery eyes, and slurred speech; he told the investigating detective he had drunk three to four light beers. Asked to perform field sobriety tests, he declined, saying he knew what would happen next and would prefer to just provide a breath sample. A preliminary breath sample read 0.147, and his two evidentiary breath samples read 0.146 and 0.145. He was arrested on suspicion of DUI. The collision reconstruction officer concluded, as the opinion states it, that his alcohol impairment and unsafe turning movement were the primary and contributing factors in the crash.
The charges, the verdict, and the sentence
The Kern County District Attorney charged DUI causing bodily injury (Vehicle Code §23153, subdivision (a)) and DUI with a blood-alcohol content of 0.08 percent or more causing injury (§23153, subdivision (b)), with allegations that he personally inflicted great bodily injury causing one victim to become comatose or suffer permanent paralysis (Penal Code §12022.7, subdivision (b)), personally inflicted great bodily injury on two victims (§12022.7, subdivision (a)), and proximately caused bodily injury to more than one victim (Vehicle Code §23558). On December 15, 2023, the jury convicted him on both counts and found the allegations true, except the subdivision (a) great bodily injury allegation as to one victim. After competency proceedings under Penal Code §1368, the court found him competent. At sentencing in November 2024, the trial court (Superior Court of Kern County, Judge John W. Lua; case No. BF176407A) denied probation, chose the low term of 16 months on count 1, added five years for the subdivision (b) enhancement, stayed a three-year subdivision (a) term, and struck the punishment for the one-year multiple-victim enhancement in the interest of justice — a total of six years and four months. The count 2 sentence was imposed and stayed under Penal Code §654.
Issue one: commenting on the refusal to perform field sobriety tests
The field sobriety tests in California are voluntary, and Mr. Schultz’s lawyer argued that the prosecutor’s closing argument — that the refusal showed he knew he was inebriated — was misconduct and shifted the burden of proof. The Court of Appeal disagreed. The prosecutor did not argue that Mr. Schultz bore any burden to prove his innocence; the comment addressed his pretrial conduct, and under People v. McFarland (1962) 58 Cal.2d 748, using a defendant’s pretrial conduct as evidence of consciousness of guilt does not shift the burden or destroy the presumption of innocence. The court added that Mr. Schultz’s own words when he declined were admissible, and that a jury could read them as an admission that he knew a breath test would show he was inebriated — so the refusal argument could not have prejudiced him in any event.
The court also rejected the related claim about the breath-test device. The defense had attacked the device’s accuracy because its accuracy checks had not always been run every 10 days as California regulations require; the prosecutor answered that the defense had called no expert to show the lapses affected accuracy. Commenting on the defense’s failure to produce evidence or logical witnesses is permissible argument about the state of the evidence, the court held, citing People v. Steskal (2021) 11 Cal.5th 332 — and here the trial court had sustained the defense objections, told the jury to disregard the comments entirely, and instructed that the prosecution alone bore the burden of proof. Given the strength of the evidence, any assumed misconduct was harmless.
Issue two: should the great bodily injury enhancements have been dismissed?
Senate Bill No. 81 added subdivision (c) to Penal Code §1385, effective January 1, 2022: courts must give great weight to listed mitigating circumstances — including multiple enhancements in a single case and a current offense connected to mental illness — when deciding whether dismissing an enhancement furthers justice, unless dismissal would endanger public safety. Mr. Schultz’s lawyer argued the trial court abused its discretion by keeping the five-year enhancement and by staying rather than dismissing the others. The court held the claim was forfeited because it was never raised at sentencing, and rejected it on the merits as well: the competency reports addressed whether he was competent to stand trial in 2023 and 2024, identified no mental illness from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual shown to have substantially contributed to the April 2019 offense, and the sentencing court had in fact exercised its discretion — choosing the low term and striking the multiple-victim punishment. Aggravating factors the trial court cited, including a blood-alcohol level about twice the legal limit and the deliberate doughnuts in a public street, could neutralize the multiple-enhancement mitigator under People v. Walker (2024) 16 Cal.5th 1024. There was no abuse of discretion, and the stay-versus-dismissal argument failed with it.
The only correction the court ordered concerns paperwork: the sentencing minute order and abstract of judgment must itemize the components of a $1,209 penalty assessment, by amount and statutory basis, and the amended abstract goes to the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation. As amended, the judgment is affirmed.
The opinion is marked not to be published in the official reports. Under California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115, an opinion with that marking may not be cited or relied on as precedent in California courts, except as that rule specifies — it still decides Mr. Schultz’s case.
Source: People v. Schultz, No. F089167 (California Court of Appeal, Fifth Appellate District, opinion filed November 18, 2026; not to be published in the official reports), listed on California Courts — Unpublished / Non-Citable Opinions (Judicial Branch of California). California files its impaired-driving charge as DUI.
Case status as stated in the opinion filed November 18, 2026: judgment affirmed as amended; remanded only for the superior court to correct the minute order and abstract of judgment to itemize the $1,209 penalty assessment. This page is general information about California DUI law, not legal advice about your case. Only a licensed lawyer in your state who knows your facts can advise you.
Charged with DUI? Start with the review.
The free case review passes what you enter — exactly as entered — to one independent local lawyer.
Start my free case review — $0DUICriminalDefenseLawyer.com is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice.