Court case — California Court of Appeal · DUI causing injury
People v. Garcia: “I blacked out” is not, by itself, an unconsciousness defense to a DUI
Charged with DUI? Start your free case review.
One local DUI lawyer reads exactly what you send and calls you back.
1. You submit → 2. We pass it along, exactly as entered → 3. One local lawyer receives it
DUICriminalDefenseLawyer.com is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Submitting this form does not create an attorney–client relationship.
On November 20, 2026, the California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, Division Five, affirmed the DUI convictions of Carlos Garcia, who drove into two cars in Los Angeles County in September 2023, seriously injuring one driver, and was found a block or two away saying he had blacked out. His lawyer on appeal, Christopher Love, argued the trial court should have instructed the jury on unconsciousness and that his trial lawyer was ineffective for not asking for that instruction. The court rejected both arguments: a driver must point to substantial evidence that he was unconscious from something other than alcohol before that instruction is owed, and a claimed memory gap, a possible head injury no expert would confirm, and his own statement that he was “tired from work” were not it. Mr. Garcia was presumed innocent at his trial; the jury convicted him, and that judgment now stands affirmed.
The crash and the arrest, as the opinion states them
According to the opinion, at about 8:47 p.m. on September 9, 2023, Mr. Garcia, driving his pickup truck under the influence of alcohol, collided with vehicles driven by Jamie Grant and Ashley Sage. Ms. Grant’s car was sent across opposing lanes into a wall; she and her daughter were taken to a hospital for minor injuries. Ms. Sage was trapped in her car with the door wedged shut while Mr. Garcia’s truck caught fire nearby; she suffered a serious leg injury and used a wheelchair, a walker, and a cane for several months, and was still in pain at her March 2025 trial. Mr. Garcia was found one or two blocks away, lying on the sidewalk with his feet propped on the curb. A paramedic found no sign of head trauma and normal vital signs, but sluggish, dilated eyes and slow, slurred speech; deputies noted an odor of alcohol, glossy eyes, and slow, mumbled, slurred speech. Two preliminary breath tests shortly after 10:00 p.m. read 0.147 and 0.145, and a blood draw at about 2:10 a.m. was also in evidence. Mr. Garcia told deputies he had passed out because he was tired from work, and after Miranda warnings said he remembered leaving his house and then “blacked out or maybe, or something,” did not remember hitting the vehicles or leaving his car, and speculated someone had pulled him from the vehicle.
The charges, the verdict, and the sentence
The Los Angeles County District Attorney charged driving under the influence causing injury (Vehicle Code §23153, subdivision (a), count one), driving with a blood-alcohol content of 0.08 percent or more causing injury (§23153, subdivision (b), count two), and hit and run resulting in death or serious bodily injury (§20001, subdivision (b)(2), count three), with an allegation that he personally inflicted great bodily injury on Ms. Sage (Penal Code §12022.7, subdivision (a)). The jury convicted him on all counts, found the great-bodily-injury allegation true, and found an aggravating circumstance proven. The trial court (Superior Court of Los Angeles County, No. PA101222, Judge Hayden A. Zacky) sentenced him to six years in state prison: the middle term of two years on count two, plus three years for the great-bodily-injury enhancement, plus a consecutive one year on count three; the count-one sentence was imposed and stayed.
Issue one: was an unconsciousness instruction owed?
California law treats unconsciousness, when it is not induced by voluntary intoxication, as a complete defense (Penal Code §26, subdivision Four; People v. Halvorsen (2007) 42 Cal.4th 379, 417). But the court held a trial judge has no duty to give the instruction (CALCRIM No. 3425) on the court’s own initiative unless the defendant first produces substantial evidence of unconsciousness from a cause other than intoxication. Mr. Garcia’s showing did not clear that bar: the mere possibility of a head injury, his emergency-room expert’s statement that a head injury “could not be ruled out” — the expert did not opine that he actually suffered one — and his inability to recall leaving the scene were not substantial evidence that he was unconscious from a head injury rather than from alcohol. The defense also called a retired sheriff’s criminalist on the reliability of the breath and blood testing; that testimony went to the test evidence, not to unconsciousness.
Issue two: was trial counsel ineffective for not asking?
For the same reason, no. A lawyer is not ineffective for failing to request an instruction the evidence does not support, and on this record there was no substantial evidence to support it. The judgment is affirmed.
The line this case draws for every “blackout” claim
Not remembering a crash is common in DUI cases, and this opinion separates two things drivers often merge: a gap in memory afterward is not the same fact as unconsciousness at the wheel, and voluntary intoxication cannot supply the defense at all. What moves the question is evidence of a different cause — a diagnosed injury, a medical event — strong enough that a jury could actually be asked to decide it. Whether any one case carries that evidence is a judgment for the lawyer who reviews the record, which is why how to fight a DUI starts with the record and not with the driver’s recollection of it.
The opinion is marked not to be published in the official reports. Under California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115, an opinion with that marking may not be cited or relied on as precedent in California courts, except as that rule specifies — it still decides Mr. Garcia’s case.
Source: People v. Garcia, No. B346003 (California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, Division Five, opinion filed November 20, 2026; not to be published in the official reports), listed on California Courts — Unpublished / Non-Citable Opinions (Judicial Branch of California). California files its impaired-driving charge as DUI.
Case status as stated in the opinion filed November 20, 2026: judgment affirmed. This page is general information about California DUI law, not legal advice about your case. Only a licensed lawyer in your state who knows your facts can advise you.
Charged with DUI? Start with the review.
The free case review passes what you enter — exactly as entered — to one independent local lawyer.
Start my free case review — $0DUICriminalDefenseLawyer.com is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice.