Free case review

Court case — Minnesota Supreme Court · DWI license case

Knapp v. Commissioner of Public Safety: a short observation period does not, by itself, exclude a breath test

Charged with DUI? Start your free case review.

One local DUI lawyer reads exactly what you send and calls you back.

1. You submit  →  2. We pass it along, exactly as entered  →  3. One local lawyer receives it

DUICriminalDefenseLawyer.com is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Submitting this form does not create an attorney–client relationship.

We — the publisher of this site, not lawyers — pass along the information you submit, exactly as you entered it, to one independent local lawyer who can help you. We do not review, summarize, or add to what you send. That lawyer, not us, decides whether to take your case.

The form is open 24/7. Your entries go to one local lawyer exactly as you entered them — nothing added.

On November 12, 2026, the Minnesota Supreme Court vacated and remanded a DWI license case that turned on a single step in a breath test: the observation period before the test. The court held that an imperfect observation period is not, on its own, a reason to exclude the test result — the district court must weigh all the evidence about whether the breath sample was contaminated. Minnesota files its impaired-driving charge as DWI, and this case concerns the civil license revocation that follows a DWI arrest, not a criminal conviction.

The challenge, as the opinion frames it

According to the opinion, Derek Alexander Knapp was arrested on suspicion of driving while impaired and consented to a breath test, which showed an alcohol concentration above the legal limit. His sole challenge to the revocation of his license was that the officer conducting the test did not adequately observe him during the required pre-test observation period, raising the concern that mouth alcohol could have contaminated the breath sample. The officer testified about his training and the observation period he conducted; the test operator confirmed the proper functioning and certification of the breath-testing instrument; and Mr. Knapp offered no evidence challenging the result other than the alleged inadequacy of the observation period.

Two courts, two answers

The Washington County District Court found the observation period inadequate, ruled the breath-test result inadmissible, and rescinded the license revocation. The Minnesota Court of Appeals reversed, holding that the district court had abused its discretion by excluding the result solely because of an imperfect observation period, and applying a framework under which the driver had to point to evidence that he had ingested or regurgitated something affecting the test.

What the Supreme Court held

The Supreme Court’s syllabus states the rule it adopted: in assessing the admissibility of a breath-test result challenged on the ground that an inadequate observation period rendered the result unreliable, an imperfect observation period is not a per se reason to exclude the result. Instead, the district court must consider all record evidence bearing on whether the breath sample was contaminated, and must admit the test result if a preponderance of the evidence shows the sample was not contaminated. The court vacated the Court of Appeals’ decision and remanded the case to the district court to apply that standard, leaving it to the district court’s discretion whether to reopen the record. The opinion was written by Justice Paul C. Thissen; Justice Reynaldo A. Aligada, Jr. took no part.

Source: Minnesota Supreme Court — Opinions Released November 12, 2026: Knapp v. Commissioner of Public Safety, No. A24-1440 (Minnesota Judicial Branch, mncourts.gov). Minnesota’s DWI statute is Minnesota Statutes Chapter 169A — Driving While Impaired (Office of the Revisor of Statutes).

What the ruling does and does not decide

The ruling sets the test Minnesota courts now apply when an observation period is challenged; it does not decide Mr. Knapp’s own case. Whether his breath-test result is admitted, and whether his license revocation stands, is for the district court on remand under the new standard, as of the opinion’s date. The observation period itself remains part of the record a lawyer examines in a DWI case — the court’s point is that a flaw in it is weighed with everything else, not treated as an automatic exclusion.

Case status as stated in the opinion released November 12, 2026: Court of Appeals decision vacated, case remanded to the district court. This page is general information about Minnesota DWI law, not legal advice about your case. Only a licensed lawyer in your state who knows your facts can advise you.

Your own case can be examined the same way

The free case review passes what you enter — exactly as entered — to one independent local lawyer.

Start my free case review — $0

DUICriminalDefenseLawyer.com is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice.

Back to Submission Form Click here ↑