Court case — California Court of Appeal · DUI license hearing

Hall v. DMV: the hearing officer who introduces the evidence can also decide the case

Charged with DUI? Start your free case review.

One local DUI lawyer reads exactly what you send and calls you back.

1. You submit  →  2. We pass it along, exactly as entered  →  3. One local lawyer receives it

DUICriminalDefenseLawyer.com is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Submitting this form does not create an attorney–client relationship.

We — the publisher of this site, not lawyers — pass along the information you submit, exactly as you entered it, to one independent local lawyer who can help you. We do not review, summarize, or add to what you send. That lawyer, not us, decides whether to take your case.

The form is open 24/7. Your entries go to one local lawyer exactly as you entered them — nothing added.

On November 16, 2026, the California Court of Appeal, Fourth Appellate District, Division One, decided a fight over who runs a DUI license hearing. After Jason Douglas Hall was arrested on suspicion of DUI in San Diego County and refused a chemical test, a single DMV hearing officer introduced the arrest evidence at his administrative per se (APS) hearing and then decided it, reimposing his license suspension. The trial court said that dual role violated due process and ordered a new hearing with two separate officials. The Court of Appeal reversed: a hearing officer who merely collects and introduces the documents law enforcement routinely sends the DMV is collecting and developing evidence, not advocating — and the $5,600 fee award that went with the trial court’s order falls with it. Mr. Hall is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

The arrest and the refusal, as the opinion states them

According to the opinion, on February 15, 2024, at about 10:00 p.m., San Diego Sheriff’s Officer Erik Plocki stopped Mr. Hall driving about 22 miles per hour over the posted speed limit and observed signs of being under the influence of alcohol — an odor of alcohol, red, watery eyes, and slurred speech. Mr. Hall refused to attempt any field sobriety tests. Officer Plocki arrested him, read him the chemical test admonishment from the DS 367 form — that his driving privilege would be suspended for one year or revoked for two to three years if he refused a breath or blood sample — and, after Mr. Hall still refused, obtained a judicial warrant; a phlebotomist drew two vials of blood at 11:22 p.m., and testing reported a blood-alcohol content of 0.25, as the opinion states it.

The APS hearing and the objection his lawyer made

The DMV suspended Mr. Hall’s license but stayed the suspension pending an APS hearing on June 6, 2024. His lawyer objected in writing before the hearing and again at its start: the DMV had been permanently enjoined from having an APS hearing officer function as an advocate for the DMV, and a single official introducing evidence while also serving as the trier of fact was exactly that. Hearing Officer Veronica Arias noted the objection and proceeded, marking four exhibits — the officer’s sworn statement, the arrest report, the body-worn camera footage, and Mr. Hall’s driving record. In a written decision issued June 7, 2024, she found reasonable cause for the stop, a lawful arrest, a proper admonishment, and a refusal, and the DMV reimposed the suspension. Mr. Hall petitioned the trial court for a writ of mandate; the trial court granted it, without prejudice to a new APS hearing run by two separate individuals, and awarded him $5,600 in fees under Government Code § 800. His lawyer in the Court of Appeal, as the opinion prints the counsel line, is Joseph K. Seipel; the DMV was represented by the Attorney General’s office.

What the Court of Appeal held

Writing for the court, Justice Kelety (Presiding Justice McConnell and Justice Buchanan concurring), followed this court’s reasoning in Romane v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2025) 110 Cal.App.5th 1002: Hearing Officer Arias began by stating she would not act as an advocate, introduced four exhibits that other DMV employees had obtained from the Sheriff’s Department by standard procedures, did not cross-examine Mr. Hall, and called no witnesses and presented no further evidence or argument for the DMV. That, the court held, is collecting and developing evidence, not advocacy. The court also rejected two further arguments: that a Driver Safety Branch chief’s subpoena for the body-camera footage tipped the hearing into advocacy (a subpoena for material already noted in the arrest record is a routine procedure, and the defense itself relied on that footage at the hearing), and that the transcript’s statement about the exhibits was anything more than a misstatement. On fees, the court held the DMV had not acted arbitrarily or capriciously, and in any event Mr. Hall had not prevailed once the judgment was reversed. The disposition reverses the judgment granting the petition and the fee order, and remands the case to the trial court (Superior Court of San Diego County, Judge Michael D. Washington; case No. D085840) to consider, in the first instance, Mr. Hall’s separate claim that the evidence does not support the refusal finding; the DMV was awarded its costs on appeal.

The opinion is marked not to be published in the official reports. Under California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115, an opinion with that marking may not be cited or relied on as precedent in California courts, except as that rule specifies — it still decides Mr. Hall’s case. The larger question is already with the California Supreme Court, which granted review in Romane on August 13, 2025 to decide under what circumstances an APS hearing officer’s relationship with the DMV violates a driver’s due process right to an impartial adjudicator, and granted review in Chi v. Department of Motor Vehicles (2026) 119 Cal.App.5th 473 pending Romane.

Source: Hall v. Department of Motor Vehicles, No. D085840 (California Court of Appeal, Fourth Appellate District, Division One, opinion filed November 16, 2026; not to be published in the official reports), listed on California Courts — Published / Citable Opinions (Judicial Branch of California). California files its impaired-driving charge as DUI. The license side of a California DUI case runs on its own track: the DMV hearing request window is 10 days from receipt of the suspension or revocation order, per California Department of Motor Vehicles — Driving Under the Influence (Administrative Per Se).

Case status as stated in the opinion filed November 16, 2026: judgment and fee award reversed; remanded for the trial court to consider the sufficiency-of-the-evidence claim on the refusal finding. This page is general information about California DUI law, not legal advice about your case. Only a licensed lawyer in your state who knows your facts can advise you.

Charged with DUI? Start with the review.

The free case review passes what you enter — exactly as entered — to one independent local lawyer.

Start my free case review — $0

DUICriminalDefenseLawyer.com is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice.

Back to Submission Form Click here ↑
Charged with DUI?Your case review is free.Tap here — no fee to ask.Start My Free ReviewTakes about a minuteTap here to fill out the form