Court case — California Court of Appeal · DUI

Banuelos-Hernandez: once the court dismissed the DUI case, it could not take the dismissal back

Charged with DUI? Start your free case review.

One local DUI lawyer reads exactly what you send and calls you back.

1. You submit  →  2. We pass it along, exactly as entered  →  3. One local lawyer receives it

DUICriminalDefenseLawyer.com is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Submitting this form does not create an attorney–client relationship.

We — the publisher of this site, not lawyers — pass along the information you submit, exactly as you entered it, to one independent local lawyer who can help you. We do not review, summarize, or add to what you send. That lawyer, not us, decides whether to take your case.

The form is open 24/7. Your entries go to one local lawyer exactly as you entered them — nothing added.

On November 17, 2026, the California Court of Appeal, First Appellate District, Division Five, decided a DUI case on a question of timing measured in hours. A Contra Costa County trial court dismissed the criminal action against Brian Banuelos-Hernandez on the morning of August 8, 2025, because the prosecution was not ready to proceed — then called the parties back that same afternoon, said it had made a mistake, and retracted the dismissal. The Court of Appeal held the retraction was beyond the court’s power: once a trial court exercises its discretion to dismiss a criminal action in its entirety, it loses jurisdiction to correct a judicial error, even one it believes was an abuse of discretion. Mr. Banuelos-Hernandez is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

The charges and the suppression fight

According to the opinion, Mr. Banuelos-Hernandez was charged on August 28, 2024 with driving under the influence of alcohol (Vehicle Code § 23152, subd. (a)) and driving with a blood-alcohol level of 0.08 percent or more (§ 23152, subd. (b)); he was arraigned on December 4, 2024 and pleaded not guilty. On May 13, 2025, his defense filed a motion to suppress evidence under Penal Code § 1538.5, which the prosecution opposed. At the June 13, 2025 hearing on that motion, the prosecution obtained a continuance over his objection — the opinion’s footnote records that one subpoenaed officer had not witnessed many of the contested events and another subpoena went to the wrong officer with the same last name — and the trial court warned that no further continuance would be considered absent unusual or emergency circumstances. His lawyers on the writ, as the opinion prints them, are Ellen McDonnell, Contra Costa County Public Defender, with Sarah Eisenhart and Dante O’Connell of that office; the People were represented by Diana Becton, Contra Costa County District Attorney, with Angela Dib and Saron Tesfai of that office.

August 8, 2025: dismissed at 9:05 a.m., retracted by afternoon

At the August 8 hearing, the prosecution said it believed it was ready, but a call to the highway patrol office the day before had found no record of its subpoenas. It asked for another oral continuance; Mr. Banuelos-Hernandez objected for lack of good cause. The trial court denied the continuance and stated, as the opinion quotes it: “The People not being ready to proceed with the case today, the case is dismissed.” The hearing ended at 9:05 a.m. At 12:43 p.m. the court emailed the parties to return at 3:30 p.m., told them it had “made a mistake,” explained that under People v. Brown (2023) 14 Cal.5th 530 it believed its dismissal was an abuse of discretion, and retracted it. The defense objected that the court had lost jurisdiction; the court disagreed and set a new date for the suppression hearing. Mr. Banuelos-Hernandez petitioned the appellate division, which denied relief, and then petitioned the Court of Appeal for a writ of mandate; the court issued an order to show cause on December 11, 2025.

What the Court of Appeal held

Writing for the court, Presiding Justice Jackson (Simons and Burns, JJ., concurring) held first that the dismissal was authorized: a trial court’s discretion under Penal Code § 1385 to dismiss an action in furtherance of justice is broad, and the court need not invoke the statute or use any particular words — the dismissal here, “made on the record and without objection,” was valid even though the trial court later said § 1385 was not its basis. The court then held the dismissal was a final judgment the trial court could not retract: a court’s inherent power to reconsider its own erroneous orders is limited to interim matters, and an erroneous dismissal is voidable, not void — correctable through a direct challenge, not by the trial court calling the case back the same day. The disposition directs that a peremptory writ of mandate issue ordering the trial court (Superior Court of Contra Costa County, Judge Michael Nieto; case No. 02-24-01388) to vacate its August 8, 2025 order retracting the dismissal; the stay the Court of Appeal had issued was dissolved, and Mr. Banuelos-Hernandez was awarded his costs in the writ proceeding.

Source: Banuelos-Hernandez v. Superior Court, No. A174508 (California Court of Appeal, First Appellate District, Division Five, opinion filed November 17, 2026; certified for publication), listed on California Courts — Published / Citable Opinions (Judicial Branch of California). California files its impaired-driving charge as DUI. The license side of a California DUI case runs on its own track: the DMV hearing request window is 10 days from receipt of the suspension or revocation order, per California Department of Motor Vehicles — Driving Under the Influence (Administrative Per Se).

Case status as stated in the opinion filed November 17, 2026: peremptory writ to issue directing the trial court to vacate its retraction of the August 8, 2025 dismissal. This page is general information about California DUI law, not legal advice about your case. Only a licensed lawyer in your state who knows your facts can advise you.

Charged with DUI? Start with the review.

The free case review passes what you enter — exactly as entered — to one independent local lawyer.

Start my free case review — $0

DUICriminalDefenseLawyer.com is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice.

Back to Submission Form Click here ↑
Charged with DUI?Your case review is free.Tap here — no fee to ask.Start My Free ReviewTakes about a minuteTap here to fill out the form